Some of you may have seen the competition I ran to win a Bump to Baby package in association with The Mumdrum a short while ago. We didn’t get time for the bump shoot as baby Frankie decided to arrive a month early, so when I met with Mum Sara it was for her beautiful daughter’s newborn shoot.
I achieved some absolutely stunning shots of Frankie which I will blog fully in the coming weeks; she goes straight in at #1 Best Sleeper on my growing list of newborns! The image below was one I was especially pleased with so I shared it as my ‘sneak peek’ on social media and also entered it into the SWPP monthly image competition, and I was absolutely thrilled when it was judged as ‘Highly Commended‘ in the societies very popular baby category.
You may not realise the work that goes in behind the scenes at a newborn shoot in order to ensure baby is sleeping peacefully then carefully moved into position for just a couple of frames per pose. Any fellow photographers reading this will appreciate the image of Frankie, who was also kind enough to give me a sleepy grin as the shutter clicked, was quite perfect.
The CEO of the baby charity The Lullaby Trust (formerly FSID) responded to the safely posed image on Twitter with the following: @EmmaLouisePhoto Disappointed that your winning photo is of a baby on its tummy asleep. Not safe sleep. #SIDS (the full exchange is here).
Just to clarify, it wasn’t a winning photo. It was one photo of many from Frankie’s session that her mother had won which I chose to share. Baby was in this position for just a few moments and this is not the usual way that her mother or I would allow baby to sleep.
Many more images were taken throughout the session, including some of Frankie on her back and also being held by Mum. The way that Frankie was posed for this image is a very common newborn pose employed by many experienced, insured and trained professional photographers but is one which should always be done so in a safely controlled environment.
Frankie had fallen asleep on her mother’s chest as she lay above and the posing area was set up ready for when she was settled enough to be transferred. The room was warm, Mum was employed to be my “spotter” – informed of what I was doing and within arms reach in case baby startled or moved suddenly. The baby was moved into a position comfortable for her, I ensured her airway was completely clear, the blanket was pulled tight and away from her face then the subsequent pose was held for no more than a few moments before she was scooped and wrapped up by Mum again ready for the next photo.
I know people who have been sadly affected by the loss of their baby and the ensuing devastation that such a bereavement causes. I am aware of SIDs guidelines. As a mother and photographer with good conscience I have a duty of care to my clients, big and small, to ensure that what I do is safe at all times.
Now I completely understand The Lullaby Trust’s concerns, though I must state that it is absolutely not my intention to promote unsafe sleep through these images. I have previously blogged about safely posing newborns because unfortunately I do frequently see images of babies posed dangerously, including similar images like Frankie’s where the baby’s arms and hands are not used to lift and support baby’s head and so their airway is blocked by blankets. Images like those horrify me which is why I feel it important to educate on the art of safely posing newborns.
Among the ‘Safer Sleep for Babies‘ advice The Lullaby Trust promotes, which is designed to significantly lower the chances of SIDs, is the ‘Back to Sleep‘ campaign.
“The position your baby is placed to sleep in each night is one of the most protective actions you can take to ensure your baby is sleeping as safely as possible. There is substantial evidence from round the world to show that sleeping your baby on their back (known as the supine position) at the beginning of every sleep or nap significantly reduces the risk of sudden infant death.”
There are lots of factors which can increase the risk of SIDS and therefore lots of ways in which you can act to reduce the risk, The Lullaby Trust have produced an excellent and informative leaflet covering all of the guidelines in detail here.
This week The Mumdrum are running SIDs awareness week and will be hosting a live web chat in the Baby Talk forum (on Thursday 17 October from 12 noon – 1pm) with Jenny Ward, The Lullaby Trust’s Head of Advice.
If you are intending to commission a photographer to capture your newborn please ensure that they are fully competent in posing newborns. If during your session the photographer doesn’t tell you what they are doing, you feel uncomfortable with the way that they are handling your baby or uneasy about anything please don’t be afraid to stop them – babies are precious, not props!
Maria - Very well said Emma! x
Claire - I am VERY shocked by the tweet you received! A child being photographed is being watched intently therefore in my opinion is not at any risk. As someone who has had both of my children photographed by you as babies, one of which was photographed asleep (because the other wouldn’t comply lol) I can’t speak highly enough about how professional and concerned with safety you were. X
Nicola - Emma, I cant believe someone said that! Your photos are beautiful and from the 2 sessions we have had with you, Matthew has always been very safe! I would recommend you without any hesitation! x
Laura - I think you have covered the point perfectly and they should be aware that the parents don’t dump a baby on you to do as you please with more that they discuss with you their babies likes and dislikes and you shot around this taking the up most care. You photographed Freya when she was 5 weeks old and I have recommended you to several friends as she was completely safe and your number one priority throughout. They are wrong to say you promote babies sleeping on their front due to one photo!
Gemma - I think that pic is adorable and it looks so natural. I’ve not had the pleasure to have you photograph my two but definitely would should the need arise, I would also gladly recommend you to friends and family x
Rhiannon - Very well said Emma, I think you’ve handled a very difficult comment in the perfect way. Please know that you have always handled my children be it at 3 years or 8 days in the most professional yet caring manner possible, I have every confidence in you. Your way with babies and children is simply perfect. Had these people known you personally or ever been present on one of your shoots they would instantly see that there is absolutely no cause for concern. Can’t wait to see the rest of the blog on baby Frankie! Absolutely gorgeous pic as always x
Lisa - I find her comments rather over the top. This is obviously a staged photo shoot not a snap of how to put your baby to bed, I think if anyone saw this and thought ‘oh yes I’ll put baby to bed naked with no nappy’ then they’d need serious intervention!
Health and safety gone mental again. Way over the top. Just take it as what it is, a beautiful photo for a lucky family to treasure.
Emma you took wonderful photographs for us of Amelie and were so tender and caring with her. Ignore the crazy pish. You rock!
Johno - The trouble is there are far too many “newborn photographers” out there these days who have absolutely no idea of what is involved in photographing newborns. It’s an artform and personally I think you do it rather well.
I know how difficult to come by a Highly Commended judgement with SWPP is. Well done.
Toni - I am really pleased with the way you have responded to the comment from the Lullaby Trust. I think you should be proud of the way you handle newborn photography, it is very obvious from seeing all the images that you take great care to ensure the baby’s safety at all times
Tracy Grant - What a lovely photo. I’m puzzled why it’s been interpreted in that way though, it’s pretty obvious that this is not the position that a baby would normally sleep in!
Caroline Watson - Very informative, thank you for sharing Emma. I had no idea about composites until I came across your site.
Frankie – Newborn Photographer Bexley Kent » Emma Louise Photo - […] to be awarded Highly Commended by the SWPP for the first image of Frankie, and I previously addressed a comment that was made regarding placing sleeping newborn babies on their front during photo sessions. […]